Special Report
English-Language Learners Q&A

English Learners Need Equal Access to Rich Texts. How One School Makes That Happen

By Sarah Schwartz — January 15, 2024 6 min read
Books sit on shelves in an elementary school library in suburban Atlanta on Aug. 18, 2023.
  • Save to favorites
  • Print

Editor’s Note: Click on the words highlighted in this story to pull up a definition and short research summary.

As the coordinator for an English-learner program, Lisa Hoelmer walks a fine line.

She knows that her EL students need extra support and specialized instruction to build their English-language skills. But she also wants them to have access to the same rich reading instruction—the high-quality texts, the in-depth conversations—that native English speakers at her school do.

At Beacon College Preparatory Charter School, a K-4 school in Memphis, Tenn., Hoelmer is working on a way to blend those two priorities. Her school uses a co-teaching model for English/language arts.

The school has adopted a knowledge-building curriculum: a program that organizes reading-comprehension instruction around conceptually connected topics, with the goal of systematically growing students’ understanding of the world. The theory behind these curricula stem from research that has found a connection between students’ general world knowledge and their ability to understand what they read.

The materials are heavy on academic, topic-specific vocabulary and complex texts, so Hoelmer and the teachers she works with have integrated language supports that prepare English learners to engage with the content.

Education Week spoke with Hoelmer about how co-teaching works at her school, what English learners need from reading-comprehension instruction, and what advice she has for other educators who might want to adopt the model.

This interview has been edited for brevity and clarity.

What does the co-teaching model look like at your school?

We needed to look at a heavy knowledge-building curriculum and figure out how to incorporate language into it. Wit & Wisdom, EL [Education], all of these knowledge-building curriculums do a great job with topic building, but they do the language piece as sort of a side note. What my job has become is to support both content and [English-as-a-second-language] teachers, and ask, how are we incorporating language development into reading comprehension as well as into building writing capacity?

For example, we’re currently in a unit on space and how people learn about space. One of the sidebars was prepositional phrases. We really leaned into the grammar piece, taught them what it was, how to understand what a preposition of time was, and then bring them back into the text to really analyze text based on sequence and time-order words.

Lisa Hoelmer

We’re reading the text Hidden Figures [a book about the Black women mathematicians at NASA who made pivotal contributions to the space program in the 1960s]. The text structure of this particular book was essentially a time-order sequence. So we were really looking for those prepositional phrases that signal, this is when something happened. We were using those prepositional phrases to build comprehension. When did Katherine Johnson develop math skills with NASA? Really helping them break apart the sentences to understand text structure, and more importantly, to understand what the hidden figures accomplished.

In general, how should reading-comprehension instruction differ for English learners and for native English speakers?

Before we begin to start teaching students the text, we have to annotate that text looking specifically for language structures—how is the text written? Specifically, what are those language structures that the author uses to get to the central idea? We’re also analyzing the text for tier-two [academic] vocabulary. What are those multiple-meaning words that a language learner may have difficulty with? We’re also thinking about sentence complexity and adverbial and prepositional phrases that trip language learners up, like “on the other hand.”

When I’m thinking about delivering that lesson, I also have to think about what background do my students need? We really do a lot of preteaching of that tier-two vocabulary but not just preteaching it—[deciding], where are we inserting it so that students are using it to talk about the text?

This preteaching of vocabulary and background knowledge, when does this take place?

Building background and the preteaching of vocabulary—initially, to get them to really understand the topic—happens first, before you even touch the text.

If you really want it to be high impact, you do your big words that they need for the culminating activity, for topic-building in the beginning, and then every day, as you retouch the text, you’re doing more vocabulary.

At your school, does this instruction just happen with English learners, or is it happening in a whole-class setting as well?

It’s happening in the whole-class setting, because we do co-teaching. Now, where we might differentiate is when we get to the independent practice when we’re doing small-group instruction—what we might need to do differently for the language learners in the classroom.

We might slow down the pace of the lesson in that small group or we might give additional vocabulary support or additional building background. But the way we do it here—and it’s been pretty fantastic—we teach the class as though everybody was a language learner.

In just six weeks, when we moved from the pullout model to the co-teach model, every student in the class, whether they’re a language learner or a native speaker, their comprehension of the text, their ability to answer standards-based questions—all students have improved. Their ability to lengthen the writing with more sentence complexity—all students have improved.

How common is this alignment of English/language arts and English-learner curricula?

It’s a new trend in ESL. Even here in Tennessee, many districts have not aligned. But alignment is, in my opinion, an equity piece. If you’re doing a pullout model, all schools have to pull out from tier-one instruction. The law is pretty clear that we can’t pull from lunch, we can’t pull from P.E. And in many states, we can’t pull from math.

If we’re pulling out of instruction and we are doing something different for ESL students, we’re effectively denying them access to tier-one [whole class] instruction. Alignment ensures that equity piece, and it ensures that ESL students are receiving tier-one, standards-based instruction.

What advice would you have for other schools that are thinking about a co-teaching model and this alignment of curricula?

First is a mindset shift. That has to start in the summer or in professional development—explaining the why and then explaining the how. In many districts, there are still teachers, ESL teachers, that really believe that they need to give ESL students something less because of the deficit mindset, right? Start with helping your teachers understand the why. And then give them the tools to make grade-level curriculum accessible to ESL students.

We say annotate your text, but what does that mean? So, really working with teachers, doing side-by-side coaching, to help them understand how to annotate the text with both reading standards and language in mind. If my standard is understanding the author’s perspective, what portions of those texts do we pull out to really reduce cognitive load for students?

The other piece I would say is, ensure that all teachers understand your ESL demographic. Here at my school, we do not have a lot of newcomers; we are essentially heritage speakers. That’s going to make my instruction different than if I had a high newcomer population.

Words Used in Story

Knowledge-building curriculum:

An approach to English/language arts instruction that aims to systematically grow students’ knowledge about the world. Literacy skills—such as applying comprehension strategies, analyzing text, writing about texts, and discussing them—are taught in the context of this content. Studies show that teaching students literacy skills in context in this way can improve reading outcomes, though many curricula in this category have not been evaluated for efficacy.

Reading comprehension:

The ability to understand what one reads. The skills that underlie reading comprehension, though, are complex and varied. Students need to be able to decode the words on the page, understand the vocabulary used, apply their own background knowledge to make sense of text, parse syntax and text structure, and monitor their own understanding as they read. Supporting students’ reading comprehension requires carefully planned and sequenced instruction.


The words used in a language. Best practices for vocabulary instruction include teaching words within a meaningful context (rather than the traditional list of unrelated words), offering children multiple exposures to a word and opportunities to use it, and connecting new words to related words that children already know.

See the full list of words used in this special report in our glossary here.

A version of this article appeared in the December 13, 2023 edition of Education Week as English Learners Need Equal Access to Rich Texts


This content is provided by our sponsor. It is not written by and does not necessarily reflect the views of Education Week's editorial staff.
Assessment Webinar
Strategies for More Effective Progress Monitoring
Learn practical, evidence-based strategies for improving school-wide acceptance and use of progress monitoring data.
Content provided by Renaissance
Jobs Virtual Career Fair for Teachers and K-12 Staff
Find teaching jobs and other jobs in K-12 education at the EdWeek Top School Jobs virtual career fair.
This content is provided by our sponsor. It is not written by and does not necessarily reflect the views of Education Week's editorial staff.
Reading & Literacy Webinar
3 Large Districts Address Science of (Pre) Reading in Pre-K
Hear how 3 large districts prioritized early literacy in their pre-K programs and their results.
Content provided by Teaching Strategies

EdWeek Top School Jobs

Teacher Jobs
Search over ten thousand teaching jobs nationwide — elementary, middle, high school and more.
View Jobs
Principal Jobs
Find hundreds of jobs for principals, assistant principals, and other school leadership roles.
View Jobs
Administrator Jobs
Over a thousand district-level jobs: superintendents, directors, more.
View Jobs
Support Staff Jobs
Search thousands of jobs, from paraprofessionals to counselors and more.
View Jobs

Read Next

English-Language Learners How a 1974 U.S. Supreme Court Case Still Influences English-Learner Education
Fifty years ago Lau v. Nichols required schools to provide language support to English learners to ensure access to public education.
7 min read
High school teacher Tara Hobson talks with a student in the school cafeteria at San Francisco International High School in San Francisco on April 19, 2016. Some districts have gone to extraordinary lengths to accommodate migrant students, who often come to join relatives, sometimes escaping criminal gangs or extreme poverty. San Francisco International High School rewrote young-adult novels at a basic level to spark the newcomers' interest in reading.
High school teacher Tara Hobson talks with a student in the school cafeteria at San Francisco International High School in San Francisco on April 19, 2016. The quality of education for English learners, including migrant students in San Francisco, has evolved over the last years in part due to landmark civil rights Supreme Court decision.
Jeff Chiu/AP
English-Language Learners Q&A WIDA to Help Mainstream Teachers Work with English Learners
WIDA aims to offer more professional development opportunities for all teachers working with English learners, not just specialists.
6 min read
View of the back of a woman lecturer giving a presentation to Ba blurred out group of diverse adults
English-Language Learners $890 Million in English-Learner Aid Is Under New Management. Why Researchers Are Hopeful
The office of English language acquisition will once again manage Title III formula grant funds.
4 min read
Education Secretary Miguel Cardona speaks during an interview with The Associated Press in his office at the Department of Education, Sept. 20, 2023 in Washington. A new federal rule threatens to cut federal money to college programs that consistently leave graduates with low pay or unaffordable debt. The gainful employment rule finalized by the Biden administration on Wednesday applies mostly to for-profit colleges, along with certificate programs at traditional universities.
Education Secretary Miguel Cardona speaks during an interview with The Associated Press in his office at the Department of Education, Sept. 20, 2023, in Washington. Cardona requested that the management of English-learner federal aid return to the office of English language acquisition earlier this year.
Mark Schiefelbein/AP
English-Language Learners Ed. Dept. Releases New Toolkit to Engage English Learners' Families
The updated English-learner family toolkit is available in four languages and as a mobile app.
3 min read
Andy, left, a first-grade student at Mount Pleasant Elementary School, works on his math homework with Sharon Francisco, an English learner teacher with Roanoke County Public Schools on April, 26, 2022, in Roanoke, Va.
Andy, left, a 1st grade student at Mount Pleasant Elementary School, works on his math homework with Sharon Francisco, an English-learner teacher with Roanoke County Public Schools on April, 26, 2022, in Roanoke, Va.
Heather Rousseau/The Roanoke Times via AP